pumping.zone/forums — Since 1999
Welcome, GuestPumper | Log In | Register
🎻 CLASSICAL PUMP REPORT  |  307 replies  |  Beethoven's 4th movement activated something  |  ClassicalPumper_Anon has not been the same since  |  "Freude, schöner Götterfunken" is now a pump command  |  🔥
🎻 "Can you pump to classical music? I tried Beethoven 9th. Full report." — 307 replies — Page 1 of 31
🎻 ClassicalPumper_Anon Regular Member Beethoven Understood the Pump ★★★ Joined: 2021 Posts: 882 The gym, with headphones, listening to Mahler
Post #1 — Posted Nov 5, 2021 Quote | Report | +Rep

I have been debating whether to post this for several weeks. I know what the reaction will be. I know TigerMandatory_Rex will respond within the hour. I know SandstormMod_DJ will have something measured and devastating to say. I am prepared for all of it.

Last Tuesday, I pumped to Beethoven's 9th Symphony in its entirety. All four movements. 65 minutes. Full pump session. Here is my report.

Movement 1 (Allegro ma non troppo): Warm-up phase. The tension building in the opening bars was surprisingly effective for stretching and light sets. The pump was nascent. Potential energy was being stored. I could feel something gathering.

Movement 2 (Molto vivace): Working sets began. The scherzo rhythm — that driving, insistent timpani — matched a deadlift cadence almost perfectly. I hit a working set PR during the fugue section. The fugue is, structurally, a pump. Multiple voices layering on top of each other, each one adding force. This is what Beethoven intended.

Movement 3 (Adagio molto e cantabile): I will be honest. This nearly ended the session. It is slow. It is beautiful. It is not a pump movement. I considered switching to Sandstorm. I did not. I held the line. I did accessory work. I did cable flies to an adagio. It was meditative. It was questionable.

Movement 4 (Ode to Joy): This is where it happened. When the cellos first introduce the theme at the 3-minute mark, something changed. My grip tightened. When the full orchestra enters — when the human voices join, when the chorus sings "Freude, schöner Götterfunken, Tochter aus Elysium" — I loaded the bar for a max attempt. The crescendo at the 7-minute mark coincided with the lift. I hit a lifetime PR. By 23 pounds.

I am not saying Beethoven is better than Eye of the Tiger. I am saying that the 4th movement activated something that I do not fully understand and that I intend to explore further.

— ClassicalPumper_Anon | Beethoven is pump music | the 7-minute crescendo is a PR attempt | I will not be moved
🐯 TigerMandatory_Rex Senior Pump Member Sandstorm Purist (but Tiger is law) ★★★★★ Joined: 2003 Posts: 14,501 Standing in front of the speaker
Post #2 — Posted Nov 5, 2021 Quote | Report | +Rep

I respond within 38 minutes, as predicted.

ClassicalPumper. I have read your entire report. I have several observations.

Observation 1: Movement 3 nearly ended your session. This is because it is not pump music. An adagio has no place in a gym. You did cable flies to an adagio. This is not pumping. This is interpretive dance with resistance.

Observation 2: Movement 4 produced a PR. I acknowledge this. I do not dismiss it. A 23-pound PR is significant. However, I must point out that Beethoven wrote "Ode to Joy" 142 years before "Eye of the Tiger" was released. If Beethoven had heard Tiger, he would have written something better. He did not have the source material. This is not his fault.

Observation 3: Rocky IV. Beethoven was not in Rocky IV. This matters and I will not explain why.

You are wrong, but in a beautiful way. I have said this before. I will say it again. You are the most beautifully wrong person on this forum.

— TigerMandatory_Rex | response time: 38 min | the hierarchy stands | Beethoven was not in Rocky IV
🎹 BeetovenPumped Junior Member The Maestro Lifted ★★ Joined: 2022 Posts: 334 Concert hall / squat rack (same energy)
Post #3 — Posted Nov 6, 2021 Quote | Report | +Rep

ClassicalPumper, I created this account specifically to support you.

I have been pumping to classical music in secret for four years. Wagner's "Ride of the Valkyries" for overhead press. Holst's "Mars, the Bringer of War" for deadlifts. Dvorak's "New World Symphony" 4th movement for squats. And yes — Beethoven 9th, 4th movement, for max attempts.

The reason it works is that classical music was written by people who understood dynamics. Not just loud-soft, but the architecture of tension and release over time. A pop song gives you the chorus every 90 seconds. Beethoven makes you wait 45 minutes for the climax. And when it arrives, the pump is proportional to the wait.

I have hit my three biggest PRs during the choral section of Ode to Joy. This is not coincidence. This is Ludwig van Beethoven, who was deaf, composing the greatest pump track of all time without ever hearing it. If that is not pump spirit, nothing is.

I will now return to lurking. Thank you.

— BeetovenPumped | came out of lurking for this | the maestro understood | returning to silence
🎵 SandstormMod_DJ Veteran Member Guardian of Sandstorm ★★★★★★ Joined: 2001 Posts: 18,910 The DJ booth (every gym should have one)
Post #4 — Posted Nov 6, 2021 Quote | Report | +Rep

I have something measured and devastating to say, as predicted.

ClassicalPumper, your report is thorough and I respect the methodology. However, I need to address the elephant in the concert hall: you cannot play Beethoven's 9th Symphony over a gym speaker system. This is a practical concern that your report does not address.

Gym speakers are designed for Sandstorm. They are designed for 136 BPM with heavy bass. They are not designed for dynamic range. The pianissimo sections of Beethoven's 9th would be inaudible under the sound of someone grunting through a set of squats. The fortissimo sections would trigger the noise complaint system that management installed in 2019.

I have been a gym DJ for 22 years. If I played Beethoven's 9th over the main system, three things would happen: (1) the 5:30 PM crowd would leave, (2) management would confiscate the aux cord, and (3) TigerMandatory_Rex would file a formal complaint in the suggestion box, which he has done 14 times for lesser offenses.

Your experiment is valid. Your results are real. But this is a headphones-only pump protocol. And headphones-only protocols exist in a different category. The communal pump requires communal music. Beethoven is a solo journey.

— SandstormMod_DJ | measured and devastating as promised | headphones ≠ speakers | Guardian since 2001
🎻 ClassicalPumper_Anon Regular Member Beethoven Understood the Pump ★★★ Joined: 2021 Posts: 883 The gym, with headphones, listening to Mahler
Post #5 — Posted Nov 7, 2021 Quote | Report | +Rep

Rex: "You are wrong, but in a beautiful way." I am going to put this in my forum signature. I am going to put this on my headstone. This is the kindest thing anyone has ever said to me on the internet.

BeetovenPumped: Thank you for coming out of lurking. The fact that you created an account for this tells me everything I need to know. We are not alone. There are dozens of us. Dozens.

SandstormMod_DJ: You are correct. This is a headphones-only protocol. I should have specified this. I would never suggest playing Beethoven over a gym speaker system. That would be an act of war. I know this. The communal pump is sacred and I would not defile it.

However, I maintain my position: in the private headphone realm, Beethoven's 9th Symphony, 4th movement, is a top-tier pump track. The 7-minute crescendo is a PR delivery system. The choral section is the most motivating thing a human being can hear while lifting heavy objects. Ludwig van Beethoven was deaf and he still composed the pump. He felt it. That is how deep the pump goes.

Next month I am attempting Mahler's 2nd Symphony — "The Resurrection." It is 80 minutes long. The final movement has a passage that I believe may produce results that exceed even the Beethoven protocol. I will report back. I will bring data.

[Editor's note: The Mahler report was posted 6 weeks later. It was 4,000 words long. The final movement did, in fact, produce a PR. The thread gained 200 replies in 48 hours.]

— ClassicalPumper_Anon | wrong, but in a beautiful way | the Mahler report is coming | headphones only, I promise
POST A REPLY
Log in to post | Register free